I've been thinking about economic development lately, since Carolyn
Lewis, our Economic Development department head, gave her notice last
month. There's general agreement that, as we look for a replacement
for Carolyn, that we need to take a much more aggressive and
collaborative – and expensive – approach to economic development
in Otsego County. Carolyn agrees, and has made some suggestions for
the Board to consider, going forward.
I'll have more to say on this soon, probably in posts about Sandy
Mathes's presentation on Wednesday, and the Governor's 'Tax-Free NY'
proposal, which eliminates many taxes for new jobs created on or
'adjacent to' SUNY facilities.
But all this (as well as graduation season) got me thinking about
my older son, who has almost finished a bachelor's degree at a good
private school in NY. One semester before graduation (he was
scheduled to graduate this December) with a degree in Computer
Science, he left school and took a job in San Francisco, as the first
employee of a well-funded internet startup. He's making about what I
made when I was first promoted to district-wide adminstrator.
He's got a list of idols – role models – in his field, as most
of us have had at one time or another. What's interesting about this
list is most of the names on it – starting with Bill Gates and
Steve Jobs – never finished college. The guy he's working for –
the guy who founded the company and secured the funding – is 20
years old and did not finish college. The same is true about the
many successful, busy, happy geeks he has run into in the month since
he's been there.
So we have a huge, successful, vibrant, creative, entrepreneurial
subculture creating great wealth and changing the culture of the
world with tecnology, and many (most?) of them did not do what, for
generations, we have assumed you had to do to create world-changing
technology.
How does that inform us when we start to ask about economic
development in Otsego County? The Governor has connected job growth
in New York to the SUNY system, and he may be right (more on that
soon). But are we making any purposeful forays into the (admittedly
unfamiliar) world of 21st century technology, where the
rules we've used for centuries have been left behind? The world has
changed, friends. We need to change with it or be left behind.
Dylan was right: “He who isn't busy being born is busy dyin'.”
Remember - blog posts migrate downward, so the most recent post is at the top; the oldest at the bottom.
Friday, June 7, 2013
Saturday, June 1, 2013
Ingraffea on Fracking
If you weren't at the Foohills production center on Thursday night
to listen to Dr. Anthony Ingraffea talk about methane gas, you were,
apparently, the only one. Everyone else was there – the house was
packed, standing room only. It was a fact-dense, but user-friendly
presentation with slides that lasted a little over an hour, followed
by Q&A. He began with data and pictures describing what kind of
well density is necessary to profitably exploit the Marcellus or
Utica shales (very dense, with sprawling well-head infrastructure);
then he laid out the data regarding pipe leakage in wells, and gas
leakage during drilling and transport (about 5%-8%), thus putting to
rest the 'clean energy' myth, especially considering that methane is
dozens of times more effective in trapping heat in the earth's
atmosphere than carbon dioxide. He ended with a proposal, which his
team will present to Governor Cuomo whenever the Governor has a
moment, setting forth a plan to move energy production in New York
State away from hydrocarbons and toward renewables, perhaps reaching
100% clean energy production in 30 years.
Sound crazy, this last bit? As crazy as the billions-of-dollars infrastructure explosion and large-scale exploitation of the environment and the political process necessary to get only 20% of the methane out of the Marcellus in a profitable manner? The more I learn what it takes to do the latter, the more I think the former is the rational choice.
Anyway, if you did miss the event, it was recorded, and I'm working on getting a link up here on the blog. Until then, you can watch Dr. Ingraffea's presentations on YouTube: just type 'Dr. Anthony Ingraffea' in the YouTube search bar, and take your pick. Here's one I've watched to get you started.
By the way, I'd love to includ a link to the Daily Star's article about the presentation... but there wasn't one (online, at least). Where were you guys?
Sound crazy, this last bit? As crazy as the billions-of-dollars infrastructure explosion and large-scale exploitation of the environment and the political process necessary to get only 20% of the methane out of the Marcellus in a profitable manner? The more I learn what it takes to do the latter, the more I think the former is the rational choice.
Anyway, if you did miss the event, it was recorded, and I'm working on getting a link up here on the blog. Until then, you can watch Dr. Ingraffea's presentations on YouTube: just type 'Dr. Anthony Ingraffea' in the YouTube search bar, and take your pick. Here's one I've watched to get you started.
By the way, I'd love to includ a link to the Daily Star's article about the presentation... but there wasn't one (online, at least). Where were you guys?
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
MOSA Future
Actually, there's no future for MOSA, at least in Otsego County;
it seems that that bridge has been burned. But what's the future of
solid waste disposal in Otsego County?
There are a number of suggestions regarding how to extract ourselves cleanly, and without unnecessary expense. Simply asking for a re-do, or taking MOSA to court without objective evidence of the true value of the properties, don't seem like good alternatives. The former has already been done, and MOSA has been particularly unresponsive. The latter will be expensive and uncertain – and Otsego County will, essentially, be paying 40% of MOSA's court costs, as well as all of ours. There may be a way to let the free market determine the properties' value; more to come, if that turns out to be a fruitful avenue of investigation.
More important than all this, at least in the long run, is the question of whether Otsego County should be in the trash business at all. There are those on the Board who answer this with an emphatic “No!,” and those who feel that leaving it all to the free market would encourage monopoly and put a lot of local trash haulers out of business.
A year or so ago, the Board indicated its interest in pursuing a combined public/private approach, where the County retained some control over the transfer station and established fees which leveled the playing field. If this were the result, fees would be designed so that the County would break even. Our consultant in this area, Hans Arnold, has told us that this approach would be economically feasible.
He has also said, when I asked him, that he didn't think that completely privatizing solid waste disposal in Otsego County would mean the loss of any jobs or the demise of any small businesses. But there was a mighty long pause before that answer.
So that's where we are at the moment. We actually have to look at all the options, talk about them, and decide relatively soon, so that we can proceed with the complex process of extracting ourselves from MOSA and replacing it with something – or nothing.
Karen Sullivan, the Director of the Planning Department, will be preparing a training for those of us who don't have extensive knowledge and experience in this area. I'll pass on what I learn, and, as always, please let me know what you're thinking.
There are a number of suggestions regarding how to extract ourselves cleanly, and without unnecessary expense. Simply asking for a re-do, or taking MOSA to court without objective evidence of the true value of the properties, don't seem like good alternatives. The former has already been done, and MOSA has been particularly unresponsive. The latter will be expensive and uncertain – and Otsego County will, essentially, be paying 40% of MOSA's court costs, as well as all of ours. There may be a way to let the free market determine the properties' value; more to come, if that turns out to be a fruitful avenue of investigation.
More important than all this, at least in the long run, is the question of whether Otsego County should be in the trash business at all. There are those on the Board who answer this with an emphatic “No!,” and those who feel that leaving it all to the free market would encourage monopoly and put a lot of local trash haulers out of business.
A year or so ago, the Board indicated its interest in pursuing a combined public/private approach, where the County retained some control over the transfer station and established fees which leveled the playing field. If this were the result, fees would be designed so that the County would break even. Our consultant in this area, Hans Arnold, has told us that this approach would be economically feasible.
He has also said, when I asked him, that he didn't think that completely privatizing solid waste disposal in Otsego County would mean the loss of any jobs or the demise of any small businesses. But there was a mighty long pause before that answer.
So that's where we are at the moment. We actually have to look at all the options, talk about them, and decide relatively soon, so that we can proceed with the complex process of extracting ourselves from MOSA and replacing it with something – or nothing.
Karen Sullivan, the Director of the Planning Department, will be preparing a training for those of us who don't have extensive knowledge and experience in this area. I'll pass on what I learn, and, as always, please let me know what you're thinking.
“Our Community Salutes”
The Board met in regular session today, primarily to approve the
membership of the LDC that is tasked with selling the Manor. One
other piece of business was conducted: we approved a resolution to
join municipalities across New York State in proclaiming May 18,
2013, as “Our Community Salutes Day” in Otsego County. This
designation honors High School graduates who have enlisted in the
armed forces.
The resolution itself is full of high-flung language, asserting that they are “patriots” and speaking of “the selflessness and courage they are demonstrating in the defense of their country.”
I've spent the best part of 40 years working in the public education system and a whole lot of that time was spent working with High School students (and their families) who, for many reasons, were not going to get to go to college when they graduated. Many of these kids pursue acceptance in the military in the same way that valedictorians pursue acceptance at Harvard – and I think these kids may get the better deal. The structure, training and travel they'll experience will certainly have a substantially positive effect on their lives.
So I joined the Board in extending my “support, gratitude and best wishes,” and I do wish them all the best. And I also wish all the best to those who won't have days to honor them.
I've never quite understood our need to focus all our patriotic attention on those who serve in the military. Patriotism is more than preparing for, and fighting wars. There are millions of other Americans (including graduating High School students) who serve their country in other ways, making the country strong and resilient – a better, safer, healthier place to live. Law officers and emergency service personnel come immediately to mind. Their jobs are always as dangerous, and often more dangerous, and they serve selflessly and honorably. Teachers and nurses also serve serve their country, and have a significant effect on the lives of those Americans – young and old, sick and well – who they serve. The list can go on: people who devote their lives to service of some sort, in jobs that are hard and demanding and often thankless, and don't make them rich.
So Godspeed and God bless, to those kids heading off to the military this summer, and thank you. And also to all the others who look forward to a career in service to their country.
The resolution itself is full of high-flung language, asserting that they are “patriots” and speaking of “the selflessness and courage they are demonstrating in the defense of their country.”
I've spent the best part of 40 years working in the public education system and a whole lot of that time was spent working with High School students (and their families) who, for many reasons, were not going to get to go to college when they graduated. Many of these kids pursue acceptance in the military in the same way that valedictorians pursue acceptance at Harvard – and I think these kids may get the better deal. The structure, training and travel they'll experience will certainly have a substantially positive effect on their lives.
So I joined the Board in extending my “support, gratitude and best wishes,” and I do wish them all the best. And I also wish all the best to those who won't have days to honor them.
I've never quite understood our need to focus all our patriotic attention on those who serve in the military. Patriotism is more than preparing for, and fighting wars. There are millions of other Americans (including graduating High School students) who serve their country in other ways, making the country strong and resilient – a better, safer, healthier place to live. Law officers and emergency service personnel come immediately to mind. Their jobs are always as dangerous, and often more dangerous, and they serve selflessly and honorably. Teachers and nurses also serve serve their country, and have a significant effect on the lives of those Americans – young and old, sick and well – who they serve. The list can go on: people who devote their lives to service of some sort, in jobs that are hard and demanding and often thankless, and don't make them rich.
So Godspeed and God bless, to those kids heading off to the military this summer, and thank you. And also to all the others who look forward to a career in service to their country.
MOSA Past and Present
It seems that the next big challenge for the County Board is going
to be the series of decisions that have to be made about MOSA, the
regional solid waste authority, named for its three county members:
Madison, Otsego and Schoharie.
Otsego County has been trying to extract itself from MOSA since before I came on the Board, mostly, as I understand, because the contract which binds the counties together requires that each provide a fixed tonnage of trash (GAT, or guaranteed annual tonnage) to the MOSA landfills in Montgomery County. If a county does not achieve its GAT at the end of the year, it pays a fee commensurate with its shortfall; this is why you get a solid waste user fee most years – to pay the GAT shortfall.
Trash tonnage, it seems, has not lived up to expectations, at least in Otsego County. In addition, those who are informed about these things assert that there are many haulers who are not bringing their trash to the MOSA landfill, for economic reasons. This is illegal, as a result of Otsego County's membership in MOSA, but it's hard for landfill operators to determine where a particular load of trash came from. And it's not in the interests of an out-of-MOSA landfill operator to turn away a paying load of trash because it came from the wrong county. Thus, the GAT remains unfulfilled year after year.
The economics of solid waste disposal are complicated and I don't intend to lay them out in detail (at this point, I probable couldn't, anyway). Long ago, when sanitation (or lack of it) was a major health issue, local governments became involved for the good of all. Today, it's not necessary, and in New York State, no local municipality of any type is required to be in the solid waste business (although every municipality is required to have a law regarding separation of recyclables). MOSA made sense decades ago, when it was established, but it doesn't now.
To add to the confusion, the MOSA administration has been completely unwilling to cooperate in Otsego County's extraction. Our county owns 40% of MOSA, and so is entitled to that proportion of the assets. MOSA took a year and a half to do an appraisal – an epic feat of foot-dragging – and then apparently over-valued the two transfer stations in Otsego County (Oneonta and Cooperstown). Since these two facilities would revert to Otsego County once we left MOSA, their value would be subtracted from the full cash value of MOSA, so it's to MOSA's advantage to over-value them.
And finally, the MOSA agreement which binds the three counties together in the regional authority expires on April 30, 2014. If there's one thing that the Board seems to agree with, it's that Otsego County will be out of MOSA on May 1, 2014, if we can't get out before. And what then?
This post is long enough; I'll comment about the possible future(s) of solid waste in Otsego County soon.
Otsego County has been trying to extract itself from MOSA since before I came on the Board, mostly, as I understand, because the contract which binds the counties together requires that each provide a fixed tonnage of trash (GAT, or guaranteed annual tonnage) to the MOSA landfills in Montgomery County. If a county does not achieve its GAT at the end of the year, it pays a fee commensurate with its shortfall; this is why you get a solid waste user fee most years – to pay the GAT shortfall.
Trash tonnage, it seems, has not lived up to expectations, at least in Otsego County. In addition, those who are informed about these things assert that there are many haulers who are not bringing their trash to the MOSA landfill, for economic reasons. This is illegal, as a result of Otsego County's membership in MOSA, but it's hard for landfill operators to determine where a particular load of trash came from. And it's not in the interests of an out-of-MOSA landfill operator to turn away a paying load of trash because it came from the wrong county. Thus, the GAT remains unfulfilled year after year.
The economics of solid waste disposal are complicated and I don't intend to lay them out in detail (at this point, I probable couldn't, anyway). Long ago, when sanitation (or lack of it) was a major health issue, local governments became involved for the good of all. Today, it's not necessary, and in New York State, no local municipality of any type is required to be in the solid waste business (although every municipality is required to have a law regarding separation of recyclables). MOSA made sense decades ago, when it was established, but it doesn't now.
To add to the confusion, the MOSA administration has been completely unwilling to cooperate in Otsego County's extraction. Our county owns 40% of MOSA, and so is entitled to that proportion of the assets. MOSA took a year and a half to do an appraisal – an epic feat of foot-dragging – and then apparently over-valued the two transfer stations in Otsego County (Oneonta and Cooperstown). Since these two facilities would revert to Otsego County once we left MOSA, their value would be subtracted from the full cash value of MOSA, so it's to MOSA's advantage to over-value them.
And finally, the MOSA agreement which binds the three counties together in the regional authority expires on April 30, 2014. If there's one thing that the Board seems to agree with, it's that Otsego County will be out of MOSA on May 1, 2014, if we can't get out before. And what then?
This post is long enough; I'll comment about the possible future(s) of solid waste in Otsego County soon.
Saturday, May 11, 2013
Home Rule
Fracking is a highly political issue, as is any issue that
involves a conflict between economic and environmental forces, and in
case we've forgotten that, the NY Court of Appeals recently upheld
the home-rule actions of the Town of Middlefield, here in Otsego
County, and Dryden, between Cortland and Ithaca. As I understand the
court system, the only way to change this decision would be to appeal
to the US Supreme Court.
So municipalities (in New York State, at least), have the power to decide what kind of industry they will allow within their boundaries. Sounds like a simple position, and it certainly makes sense, but politics does funny things to sense. You may remember the County Board vote supporting home rule last year, when a large minority of the Board voted against the ability to choose for ourselves.
But now that there's some stability to the notion of home rule here in NY, the rules, so to speak, change. Some have argued that the decision gives Governor Cuomo some political breathing room to approve fracking, ending the years-long statewide moratorium, since municipalities now have the right to decide otherwise. Others suggest that the gas industry will be less willing to develop drilling strategies in an region that is a checkerboard of differing regulations. The decision will certainly take some of the pressure off state regulators who, if the NY experience is anything like other states, will not be given the resources to ensure any kind of quality oversight.
I think it's a win for democracy – the kind of democracy that most of us participate in and feel comfortable with: local government. Neighbors and fellow-townspeople will get together to decide what's best for them. They'll know their town, and take their local knowledge into account. They can change their mind if they want.
Gas and oil companies will survive and flourish, regardless. I have little patience for the argument that we can't make it more difficult for corporations to do their jobs. Inflexible companies will wither, and resilient companies will make adjustments and succeed – just as they have for centuries. Under no conditions is it acceptable to relinquish our autonomy in order to protect the profits of ultra-wealthy international corporations.
So municipalities (in New York State, at least), have the power to decide what kind of industry they will allow within their boundaries. Sounds like a simple position, and it certainly makes sense, but politics does funny things to sense. You may remember the County Board vote supporting home rule last year, when a large minority of the Board voted against the ability to choose for ourselves.
But now that there's some stability to the notion of home rule here in NY, the rules, so to speak, change. Some have argued that the decision gives Governor Cuomo some political breathing room to approve fracking, ending the years-long statewide moratorium, since municipalities now have the right to decide otherwise. Others suggest that the gas industry will be less willing to develop drilling strategies in an region that is a checkerboard of differing regulations. The decision will certainly take some of the pressure off state regulators who, if the NY experience is anything like other states, will not be given the resources to ensure any kind of quality oversight.
I think it's a win for democracy – the kind of democracy that most of us participate in and feel comfortable with: local government. Neighbors and fellow-townspeople will get together to decide what's best for them. They'll know their town, and take their local knowledge into account. They can change their mind if they want.
Gas and oil companies will survive and flourish, regardless. I have little patience for the argument that we can't make it more difficult for corporations to do their jobs. Inflexible companies will wither, and resilient companies will make adjustments and succeed – just as they have for centuries. Under no conditions is it acceptable to relinquish our autonomy in order to protect the profits of ultra-wealthy international corporations.
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
The LDC Vote
Today at the Board Meeting, the Board voted to establish a Local
Development Corporation and transfer the ownership of the Manor to
that organization. The County retains a firm grip on the finances
and operation of the Manor, and the LDC's sole purpose is to sell it
to... well, we hope to the bidder who represents the highest quality
of care in their current facilities.
I offered an amendment to the resolution which separated the creation of the LDC (which would remain in the resolution) and the transfer of the Manor (which would be struck from the resolution). There was a fair amount of debate on this amendment, but it failed, with only John Kosmer and myself voting for it.
I had originally argued that the LDC's mission should include submitting their final choice to the Board for a vote (before the Department of Health process started), so the Board could take responsibility for the choice, like many of us had promised to do. It turns out, according to County Attorney Ellen Coccoma, that this process would trip us into a 215 situation – it would be seen as Board action to sell the Manor, and as such we would have to sell to the highest bidder, full stop.
I'm still not convinced that the 'highest responsible bidder' means what many think it means – 'responsible' equalling 'able to pay' – but I had to go with our attorney's advice, given the time constraints.
The amendment that I did offer – separating the creation of the LDC from the transfer – was an attempt to do the same thing: to allow the Board to vote on the LDC's final choice of buyer. I offered the amendment for two reasons. First, as you know, I'm concerned about the Board giving up its right to take responsibility for the final sale. This would allow the Board to transfer the Manor to the LDC for sale after the successful bidder had proven that it had a high-quality track record. Second, I thought that we needed to have a public debate on this, if for no other reason than to honor those members of the public who have spent as many months working on this issue as we have. I think it's important to note that in all the public comment sessions and public hearings on this issue, only an infinitesimal percentage of those who participated were in favor of the sale and/or the LDC. The LDC/transfer separation was a legitimate solution offered by many of the public, and today it got a hearing.
The final vote on the full resolution was 11-3, with Keith McCarty, John Kosmer and myself voting against. I think we need to sell the Manor – there are no alternatives left, it seems – but I am unhappy with the LDC process, especially the fact that it takes the responsibility from those of us who were elected to exercise that responsibility.
I offered an amendment to the resolution which separated the creation of the LDC (which would remain in the resolution) and the transfer of the Manor (which would be struck from the resolution). There was a fair amount of debate on this amendment, but it failed, with only John Kosmer and myself voting for it.
I had originally argued that the LDC's mission should include submitting their final choice to the Board for a vote (before the Department of Health process started), so the Board could take responsibility for the choice, like many of us had promised to do. It turns out, according to County Attorney Ellen Coccoma, that this process would trip us into a 215 situation – it would be seen as Board action to sell the Manor, and as such we would have to sell to the highest bidder, full stop.
I'm still not convinced that the 'highest responsible bidder' means what many think it means – 'responsible' equalling 'able to pay' – but I had to go with our attorney's advice, given the time constraints.
The amendment that I did offer – separating the creation of the LDC from the transfer – was an attempt to do the same thing: to allow the Board to vote on the LDC's final choice of buyer. I offered the amendment for two reasons. First, as you know, I'm concerned about the Board giving up its right to take responsibility for the final sale. This would allow the Board to transfer the Manor to the LDC for sale after the successful bidder had proven that it had a high-quality track record. Second, I thought that we needed to have a public debate on this, if for no other reason than to honor those members of the public who have spent as many months working on this issue as we have. I think it's important to note that in all the public comment sessions and public hearings on this issue, only an infinitesimal percentage of those who participated were in favor of the sale and/or the LDC. The LDC/transfer separation was a legitimate solution offered by many of the public, and today it got a hearing.
The final vote on the full resolution was 11-3, with Keith McCarty, John Kosmer and myself voting against. I think we need to sell the Manor – there are no alternatives left, it seems – but I am unhappy with the LDC process, especially the fact that it takes the responsibility from those of us who were elected to exercise that responsibility.
Monday, April 29, 2013
Welcome!
Welcome to all who found their way here through my recent constituent mailing. This is my primary method of communicating with all of you. I hope you'll browse my thoughts and actions on the Board through these blog posts, and leave comments when you have something to say. I take comments very seriously, and I'll respond to as many as possible.
Of course, you can also contact me at the e-mail address link at the top right of the blog.
Hope to hear from you!
Of course, you can also contact me at the e-mail address link at the top right of the blog.
Hope to hear from you!
Sunday, April 28, 2013
LDC Solution Suggestion
I've been reading a lot of detail about the legalities of LDCs
lately, as they relate to how the Board will handle the sale of the
Manor. It'll all be over, one way or another, on Wednesday, and I've
still got the same concerns about this path as I did when I last
wrote about it.
However, I've got a partial solution. It turns out that the Board can write anything it wants into the LDC's establishing document. It can configure the Corporation, and its relationship to the Board, any way it wants.
So – what if the LDC's mission was to write and distribute the RFP (request for proposals), vet the bidders, and make a choice among them – and then present that choice to the Board, which will make the final decision?
Harris-Beach has argued against the Board making the final decision regarding the successful bidder, mostly because, in politics, things change. Every Board member is running in November, and we already have two members who are not seeking reelection. We could have a whole new approach come January 1, 2014.
This is a valid point. However, real democracy is often messy and complicated, and, if we're doing it right, change is actually a reflection of the will of the people. But even more important, the timeline for this sale suggests that a successful bidder will be chosen well before December. After that, the bidder will have to be approved by the NYS Department of Health. That could take a year or more. But the Board approval that I'm suggesting would take place after the LDC has settled on a successful bidder, but before that bidder begins the DoH process.
At this moment in time, a majority of the Board is willing to hand off the Manor decision to an LDC. Why wouldn't we be willing to affirm that decision – and take responsibility for it – with one vote?
However, I've got a partial solution. It turns out that the Board can write anything it wants into the LDC's establishing document. It can configure the Corporation, and its relationship to the Board, any way it wants.
So – what if the LDC's mission was to write and distribute the RFP (request for proposals), vet the bidders, and make a choice among them – and then present that choice to the Board, which will make the final decision?
Harris-Beach has argued against the Board making the final decision regarding the successful bidder, mostly because, in politics, things change. Every Board member is running in November, and we already have two members who are not seeking reelection. We could have a whole new approach come January 1, 2014.
This is a valid point. However, real democracy is often messy and complicated, and, if we're doing it right, change is actually a reflection of the will of the people. But even more important, the timeline for this sale suggests that a successful bidder will be chosen well before December. After that, the bidder will have to be approved by the NYS Department of Health. That could take a year or more. But the Board approval that I'm suggesting would take place after the LDC has settled on a successful bidder, but before that bidder begins the DoH process.
At this moment in time, a majority of the Board is willing to hand off the Manor decision to an LDC. Why wouldn't we be willing to affirm that decision – and take responsibility for it – with one vote?
Friday, April 26, 2013
Head Start in Oneonta
You've probably
heard about the sequester cuts in funding to Opportunities for Otsego
for Head Start, which it administers. The news made the front page
of the Star, above
the fold. Head Start money doesn't go through the County (as much Federal
money does), so I'm just a spectator to this tragedy. Job losses,
families in unnecessary turmoil.
I'm also a citizen of a democracy, so I wrote our Senators and Congressman. Here's what I wrote:
I'm also a citizen of a democracy, so I wrote our Senators and Congressman. Here's what I wrote:
My anger and frustration with the sequester came to a head yesterday when I discovered that, due to the reduction in Federal grants funding Head Start, Oneonta Head Start will have to lay off eight people, and deny day care service to thirty two families, starting on July 1.
My wife and I have worked with Head Start, in a number of ways, for decades. These are people who work hard for pitifully low wages, and do a lot of good for a lot of kids. For the most part, these folks are holding on the best they can, economically. Those who are laid off will struggle with unemployment, and many of those families will fall (or be pushed?) into poverty. The families who depended on the high-quality day care will have their lives transformed, and not in a good way. There is no job-creating going on here – just the opposite.
Congress and the Administration created the sequester with the thought that fear of the consequences of really draconian and irrational cuts would motivate them to cut a deal to avoid the pain. The truth is, the sequester is designed to focus the pain on the most vulnerable, the least resilient, the least able to adapt and adjust.
This is not the way we serve our constituents. Please exhibit the courage and leadership necessary to right this wrong.
I sent that off on Wednesday; today I
read that Congress has manged to find a way to lessen the impact of
the sequester on themselves and other middle and upper class
Americans. This morning, I wrote to our representatives again:
You have found a way to shuffle sequestered funds in the Transportation Department so that Senators and Congressmen, and other middle and upper class Americans, don't have to wait as long at the airport.
Now it's time to find the same flexibility in the Department of Health and Human Services so that the Oneonta Head Start doesn't have to lay of 8 people and leave 32 families without daycare starting July 1.
It's important for you to understand that, here in the real world, extraordinary action on the behalf of the privileged and lack of action on behalf of the vulnerable and disadvantaged looks just like that.
Please do the right thing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)