Remember - blog posts migrate downward, so the most recent post is at the top; the oldest at the bottom.

Thursday, July 30, 2015

PRGS

One of the Board committees I'm on is the Performance Review and Goal Setting Committee (PRGS); this is my second year on that committee. Last year, under the leadership of Beth Rosenthal, PRGS developed a new system and forms for evaluating department heads. This year, under Ed Lentz's leadership, we have begun a bi-annual evaluation process, which includes the Board committee that oversees the department, reviewing written assessments and meeting with department heads to go over them.

It's a bittersweet process: on one hand, most of our department heads are doing a great job with few resources, and we hate to divert any time or energy to engage them in a process which, essentially, tells them that. On the other hand, there are opportunities for improvement scattered around the group, and some of them are pretty important. So far, I think we have been able to address these areas needing improvement pretty well, and have developed some strategies that should lead to improvement.

I think that it's important that the citizens of the County know that we, the Board, are doing the often-difficult and uncomfortable – but essential – job of oversight, keeping track of the job performance of those professionals who are responsible for enormously varied work that the County does.

This process is also a way for us to get feedback from departments regarding how we're doing in the job of supporting those departments. During the interviews and document reviews, two pieces of feedback have consistently appeared. First, we hear that over the years, the Board has cut too many positions and this has threatened the mission of a number of departments. This second issue is the Board's tendency to micromanage departments and thus, in some cases, give department heads conflicting signals.

Both of these are true. However, I fear we will not be able to address these issues really effectively until the majority shifts to the party which feels that the Board should be engaged in longer term planning and goal-setting, and that we should leave the operation of the departments to the department heads.

Saturday, July 25, 2015

SWEC, Among Others

For much of the last few months I've been working six and seven days a week, and have not had a chance to do what I had done in the past – attend meetings of committees of which I was not a member. I think it's essential to the training of any Board member (although not many others do) as most of the detail work of the Board is discussed, debated and voted on in Committee. The Administration Committee is most instructive, as many if not most proposals have to be approved by Admin after being approved in the home Committee. Admin meetings are usually long, but very instructive.

I'm especially looking forward to returning to Solid Waste/Environmental Concerns (SWEC) Committee meetings in the fall, when my schedule loosens up a bit. SWEC oversees, and makes decisions about, most of the environmental policy that the County has authority over. It oversees the Otsego County Soil and Water Conservation District which, despite its name, is a state agency partly supported by the county's budget. The Soil and Water folks are always doing things that interest me, including stream bank management (you probably know I live right on Oneonta Creek), hydroseeding, agricultural plastic recycling, and lots more. Hopefully, I'll have more detailed reports later on. Last fall, I participated in an all-day tour of Otsego County farms put on by S&W, looking at waste management projects that improve overall production while reducing the organic wastes that run into our streams and rivers. There's another one scheduled this fall.

SWEC is also still working on the solar project I reported on last year; the sticking point has been location. We need about ten clear acres which is reasonably near an appropriate power line, and that last part is the problem. The solar project will, to oversimplify, be selling power to the NYSEG grid, and it seems that NYSEG really doesn't want it (as you'd expect, they'd rather we bought our power from them). They have, apparently, been less than totally cooperative. But there are real physical constraints, and we haven't yet found a location that meets all the requirements.

SWEC has also spun off a 3R Task Force (Reduce, Reuse, Recycle) which I am part of.  It is looking into some wholesale recycling projects in the county, including textiles, mattresses and expanded polystyrene (styrofoam). Stay tuned for more.

And finally, the new solid waste system seems to be working out well. SWEC has worked through some problems with the Northern Transfer Station, outside Cooperstown, caused by its small size and the increased usage. These difficulties should be addressed at this point, partly by rearranging the site, and partly by a new permit which allows a good deal more tonnage to be collected. And we seem to be making some money at the end of the day (actually, the end of the year): the more waste that comes through the two transfer stations, the better off we are, so we make money in the summer and pay Casella in the winter. Overall, we seem to come out ahead.

Friday, July 24, 2015

Eventually, We Need to Take a Look

As promised, a new beginning...

And what better way to begin again than to weigh in, at least a little bit, on the Oneonta Town-City merger conversation. A somewhat loud, and, at times, unpleasant conversation, to be sure.

My position is simple: let's take a look. I think that no one really knows what the merged landscape would look like for sure, in detail. Those who come closest are probably Bill Shue and Al Colone, of GO-EDC, two enterprising citizens who have been beating the bushes for a merger and, for that reason, have done an enormous amount of research and investigation. This is all the more creditable when we consider that no one is paying them anything for all that work.

Bill and Al make a very compelling case, but they're just one side of the coin. They are not disinterested, and never claim to be. They are citizens trying to make something good (as they see it) happen in a democracy.

So we need to find out for sure. It seems that everybody loves a study, and everybody hates one. There have been other studies, and many point to them as evidence that no more need be done. However, they were done a relatively long time ago, considering the very recent developments in the state incentive world.

So it seems to me that we don't know the answer – we don't know what a merger would end up doing for us, or to us, City or Town. We are, incredibly, all speaking from ignorance when we put forward a strong opinion on this topic. So lets find out.

A merger study is probably dead for now. To be fair, it seems that it would be hard for any Oneonta Town Councilperson to get re-elected after supporting a merger study. Unfortunately, many Towns-people are living on the myth of higher taxes for the Town and lower taxes for the City. Bill and Al have debunked that one, but it still lives and breathes and determines the politics of the Town. No one – certainly not myself – would pursue a merger that would raise taxes significantly on anyone.

There are other things to think of, at least for me, and for the other four County Representatives involved in this. As a larger City could capture a much larger proportion of the sales taxes generated within its borders (a very substantial sum), the implications for the County – and for the county's taxpayers – could be significant.

We shall see. I suspect this issue will re-emerge after the new City Council, Town Council and Board of Representatives are seated in January. Then we may have enough breathing room to take a good look

Wednesday, July 15, 2015

The Blog is Back!

I see that my last post on this blog was November 11, exactly one week before my mom died, down on Long Island.  She was 95 and had lived independently in the house I grew up in until the day before she died, when she went into the hospital with what was diagnosed as colitis and died the next day of a massive infection leading to heart failure.  

She had a great life and was a fascinating person.  She was the matriarch of the family history and heirlooms.  As the extended family gathered, we all acknowledged that she was the last of her generation, and the responsibility of being the "grown up" in a family that had descended from Revolutionary War soldiers and Jamestown settlers had come to rest on me, the oldest of my generation.  A weighty mission, indeed.  So, after a long period of time sorting and clearing out her house and fulfilling endless executor duties, I set off across the country to deliver the mementos of a great family to my cousins and sons:  photo albums, handwork, china, portraits, scrapbooks, journals, jewelry and accessories, an ancient rifle, mirrors, and nicknacks we had seen on her shelves for half a century.  In two and a half weeks I drove coast to coast, through a dozen or more National Parks, stopping at the homes of four family members, and, on the way home, taking an end run south around the Rockies to avoid an April snowstorm.   

I'm not sure who, if anyone, reads this blog, so I'm allowing myself luxury of writing about my mom and my trip west as a way to apologize for letting the blog go since November.  Life just got to complicated, and some things had to go.  I put a high priority on my job of representing you in Cooperstown - sometimes driving up from working on the LI house to attend a meeting, then driving right back - but it's been a disruptive few months.  And then in February a nearby school district lost its School Psychologist and asked me to fill in for the rest of the school year.  I'll finish my last two reports on Friday.  

So - my apologies for the gap.  I hope to pick it up immediately and then continue to provide you with communications from the County Board in Cooperstown.

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Public Comment on the Budget

Further info on opportunities for the public to speak to the Board about the 2015 budget:
  •  Monday, November 17 at 9:15AM - County Board Chambers in the County Office Building, Cooperstown:  Regular mid-month meeting, called primarily to complete work on a public law, but there will be a time for public comment. 
  • Friday, November 21 at 1:00PM - County Board Chambers in the County Office Building, Cooperstown:  Full-Board meeting of the Budget Review Committee; as a Committee meeting, it is open to the public and public may comment.
  • Monday, December 1 at 6:00PM - Otsego County Courthouse:  The public hearing specifically to address the 2015 budget.  This is the best forum for comment on the budget - and typically, noone comes, and we adjourn at about 6:02PM.
  • Wednesday, December 3 at 10:00AM - County Board Chambers in the County Office Building, Cooperstown:  Regular monthly Board meeting; there will be a time for public comment.
  • There might be a December mid-month meeting of the Board if necessary; public comment will be heard.

Monday, November 10, 2014

Budget Update

A couple of news items from the Budget Review Committee's meeting last Wednesday afternoon:

The Elm Park Church Senior Meals site will remain in operation at least through March 31.  The extension was granted to keep the change from occurring in the difficult winter months, and to allow the Director of the Office for the Aging, Frances Wright, more time to find a more appropriate solution than Nader Towers/242 Main.  It will also provide some time for the Elm Park folks to consider lowering the rent - something is better than nothing.  This is all good news, but good news with a time limit.  Stay tuned, and keep communicating with Board members.

Secondly, $35,000 was added to the Otsego County contribution to Cornell Cooperative Extension, raising that contribution from, I believe, $125,000 to $160,000.


Noone on the Board doubts the importance of agriculture to the past, present and future of Otsego County.  The question is, how do we encorage and support this industry as effectively as possible?  Without a comprehensive plan, of course, we have no idea.  So the funding of CCE has become a controversial hot potato, and our contribution has ebbed and flowed with the political winds (sorry about the mixed metaphor).

I think we need to do everything we can to grow our agricultural sector.  CCE is in that business, and they've gone a fair way toward proving that they can be effective.  Further funding will enable us to re-subscribe to the CNY Dairy and Field Crop Team, and to hire a local Ag Educator to focus on dairy and field crop issues.  With the possible resurgence of hops as a sustainable crop, we should do everything we can to encourage and support this initiative.

In the 19th century, Otsego County was the center of the hops world; most of America's hops were grown here and in surrounding counties.  No reason we can't do it again:  we've got the same land, the same determined work ethic, and all we might need is some help remembering how to do it. 

Update:  I forgot to add this caveat:  the budget is still in draft form and can be changed by Board action.  The next whole Board budget meeting is Friday, November 21, at 1:00PM in the Board chambers in the County Office Building in Cooperstown.  If' you've got something to say about the budget, join us.

Saturday, November 8, 2014

Property Tax Auction

I'd like to say a word or two about the tax auction controversy.

If you don't pay your County property taxes, a four-and-a-half year process starts, during which you receive dozens of notices in the mail and, if you own a residential property, the Treasurer himself goes out to the property to try and contact you in person.  There's a deadline, which in Otsego County's case is not the day of the sale but, instead, about a month and a half before the sale.  If payment isn't made by the deadline, the property goes to auction.  State law prohibits you from bidding on your own property.

In this kind of system, where people's homes are often at risk, it's important to make sure that the owners have every opportunity to pay the back taxes and get their homes off the auction list.  In Otsego County, the notification process is longer and more intense than in many other counties.  Dozens of contacts - including face to face - during four and a half years represents diligence in the extreme.

But eventually, there's a deadline.  In some counties, it's the day of sale.  When that's the case, and properties are withdrawn from sale minutes before it begins, buyers become frustrated and don't return.  In Otsego County, the deadline is more than a month before the auction.  This creates a period of time when the property isn't sold, but during which the owner can't pay the taxes any more.  

A deadline is a deadline, regardless of what comes after.  But when people's homes are at stake, tragic stories unfold.  You'd like to provide a second chance - but the County has provided four and a half years of second chances.  Any exception will embroil the County and its taxpayers in years of litigation when every other tax delinquent property owner demands - and rightly so! - the same exception.

This, then, is the very last step in a very long process that has given the property owner every opportunity to get back on track and retain their home.  Our heartbreak - and it is real - might be eased if we understood that essential concept.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

Budget Time Again

We've had some good financial news and positive events this year – increased sales tax, the sale of the Manor, the dissolution of MOSA, the Oneida Nation's ongoing payment in return for our agreement to stay out of the casino business.  So budget time is not as anxiety-producing as it has been.  There is even the possibility of a miniscule tax reduction.

However, costs continue to rise – the usual suspects, including salaries, health insurance, and unfunded mandates, as well as the usual collection of odds and ends.  So cuts still have to be made.

Some notes on a couple of budget issues.  First, the M&C employees (Managerial and Confidential – everyone who is not represented by a union) are finally going to get their raise, the first in seven years.  It is substantial enough to not be embarrassing, but does not put our County in a salary range which is competitive statewide.  I continue to be astounded at the high quality employees, many in leadership positions, that we retain, year after year, even though they have been treated so badly.  They need to continue to be adequately compensated as the years go by.  And their raises should actually be given to them, not like last year, when the Board approved them in December and the majority of the Admin Committee took them away.

There is some substantial controversy over the closing of the Elm Park Church senior meal center in Oneonta, as well.  This is appropriate controversy, and not unexpected.  The Office for the Aging operates the meal center and a few offices in the church, for which we are charged $13,000 each year (down from the low $20,0000s a couple of years ago).  The meal site will be merged with the existing meal site at Nader Towers, and the offices will be moved to vacant rooms at the County Office Building at 242 Main Street in downtown Oneonta.  In both places, parking is the issue, and having visited both I feel that these moves will be a very big step down. 

I was on the Health and Ed Committee my first two years, and I was active in helping to find an alternative to the too-expensive Elm Park site.  We looked at Nader Towers and 242 Main, and discarded them as alternatives, mostly because of the parking issues.  This year the Health and Ed Committee cut the Elm Park payment and recommended the moves, and the Budget Review Committee approved this move.  Both committees are chaired by Don Lindberg, who represents the eastern end of the County.  He's the one to contact if you feel strongly about this, as I do.

And, finally, there is the County Clerk's office.  The County Clerk is elected, and so has a level of independence from the Board, and she has used that independence often in the past.  Cutting services at the DMV offices in Cooperstown makes sense:  patronage is declining sharply, as more and more people do their DMV business online, and Otsego County does not collect fees for online interactions.  The Clerk's threat to keep the offices (which are losing money) open and suspend out-of-state work (which does produce revenue) does not make sense, and seems to me to be done out of spite, in response to the Budget Review Committee's cuts in her department.  As a taxpayer, I'm appalled. 

More to come on the budget. Stay tuned, as usual...

Thursday, October 16, 2014

Overdue Summary

Sorry for the lack of posts here during the middle part of the year. I just counted seven major theatrical productions I've been a big part of since April; that, and taking on another part time position (temporary, if all goes well) left little time for anything. In addition, I really don't have a lot of evidence that this blog is read by anyone; Blogspot sends me pageview numbers, but doesn't screen for bots, and I've had no comments or e-mail since... forever, it seems.

Anyway, a summary of the important pieces of work going on in the County. First, of course, is the sale of the Manor; earlier this week, we traded the keys for a little more than $18 million, and everyone was happy. Well, perhaps with the exception of some of the employees who chose to stay, whose pay and benefits (actually not finalized at this point) have been substantially reduced.

It's important to note that up until this week – when the Manor was owned by the County – pay scales were much higher than those at other nursing homes in the region. This was a double problem: not only did the County have a significantly larger payroll, but Medicare bases its reimbursements on the 'regional average' cost of running a nursing home – which was, of course, much lower than our cost. So our costs were high, and our reimbursements were low, and that is much of the story of the subsidy that the taxpayers had to provide to keep the doors open each year (about $5 million this year).

Add to that the fact that we probably had 40 more staff at the Manor than was needed; staffing patterns were perpetuated from the days of the Meadows “because that's the way we always did it.” The new owner will adjust things to come into balance, and will make a profit, and wages will no doubt rise as time goes on. This whole process was clear two years ago, when we began preparing for the sale, and should not be a surprise to anyone.

The Manor will continue to be a good place to live and a good place to work.

There are rustlings and rumors throughout the Board regarding the issue of raises for management and confidential (M&C) employees (everyone not in a union). They haven't gotten a raise in seven years, a situation which is an abomination and cannot be treated as anything else. The great fear is that those who have resisted the raises – there was always a justification to say “not enough money right now” - who have been in the majority all along, will approve token raises and then be able to shelve the subject for years to come. “They got a raise; we can't just spend whenever we want to; where's the money going to come from?”

I'll tell you where it'll come from – right off the top. There is no higher priority. Let them ask those questions about anything else the County pays for, but this abomination must be ended. Our fiscal conservatism has, on the backs of our employees (and ex-employees who have been laid off), put us in a relatively healthy position. St. Lawrence County, up on the Canadian Border, is borrowing a million dollars a year just to keep the lights on. We have a healthy fund balance, no more Manor subsidy, no more MOSA GAT (in fact, we're making money on solid waste), and sales tax may be up. There are challenges in the budget, of course, but when the cuts come, M&C raises must be off the table.

And finally, there is a little movement regarding the huge solar array in the 'boneyard' north of Laurens.  Solar City came to present to the whole Board last month, and although there is a certain amount of foot-dragging from the usual suspects, there is also a good deal of interest. Stay tuned.

Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Morning for Solar

In a post this January called “Sunrise for Solar?” I described a Solid Waste/Environmental Concerns (SWEC) committee meeting at which we discussed a proposal to build a 2MW solar array on empty County land and buy the power from the private consortium of local investors who would pay for the array to be built. Shortly after that, I attended a NY Association of Counties conference in Albany, where I sat in on a workshop featuring a company called Solar City, which made the same proposal, except that they, Solar City, would own the array.

I brought this company to the attention of SWEC Chair Linda Rowinski, and she made contact with Solar City. At today's SWEC meeting, they made their second presentation. At this point, the array could be 3MW (80% of the County's needs) and it could be sited on a tapped out gravel pit (apparently called a 'boneyard') on County Rt. 11, between West Oneonta and Laurens. As in the January presentation, Solar City would build, own and maintain the array, and sell the power to the County at a rate guaranteed for 20 years – a rate which starts out lower than current costs.

It turns out that there is an annual round of NYS funding that Solar City, and the competing company I wrote about in January, are involved in, and they needed to have our approval to proceed in our behalf. SWEC gave that approval to both companies; the plan is to go with the plan that earns approval. If both are approved, we can choose between them. Good news! And more to come.

Two interesting points. When balancing the options, the Committee did not (at least out loud) consider the value of solar vs. hydrocarbons as a source of electric power. I think that would be worth a cent or two – probably more – per kilowatt hour, if it came down to that. But I'm not a Committee member, just an interested Representative, so I didn't have a say.

Second, there was some mention of the fact that the old boneyard was screened from view by an encircling berm (which is, apparently, true of all working gravel pits); this was seen as an advantage, because it would be hidden from view. I would prefer the array be in plain sight. We need to see the future, because the future – renewable power from clean, nearly eternal sources – is beautiful.