Remember - blog posts migrate downward, so the most recent post is at the top; the oldest at the bottom.

Thursday, August 1, 2019

Life on the Board II - Planning and Timliness

From the budget, I'll move on to a potpourri of issues, plans, challenges, obstacles, etc., that are facing the Board presently. They were all discussed, in some form, at the Budget Committee meeting on Monday July 29.I'll be sending them in installments.

First, a very high-altitude overview of two fundamental issues that may or may not come as a surprise.
First: The County Board really, really stinks at planning ahead, long-term. I think we have a long history of dealing only with what's right in front of our noses.

In my opinion, and in the opinion of most of the Board members I have spoken with about this, we have a truly excellent group of Department Heads, and one of the things almost all of them do very well is long-term planning. So each individual department is looking down the road and making plans for what's ahead for them. However, when it comes to the bigger projects, and taking the Strategic Plan and using it to plot the overall direction of the County and its various components – this seems always to fall down the list of priorities and we often go month after month without making headway on most of them.

For instance, here is a representative sample of some of the projects we must address (and more on each of these later):
  • Demolish Highway garage and build a new one – move the whole Dept to a new location?
  • Perform $1.5M repairs and renovations on 25-year-old jail
  • Decide on how to upgrade/sell/use as is – 242 Main St., the County building on Oneonta's Main Street
  • Replace Emergency Services training facility
We've been talking about, and putting off, these projects for years (the Jail renovations are occurring now, and should be finished by the end of the year. But there are still decisions to make here).

All of these (and other examples) cost a lot of money, and that's probably another reason we tend to avoid making progress – at some point in the process, real money will need to be spent.

This all needs to change, and I, for one, am hoping that adding a County Manager/Admin to the mix will help a lot.

Which brings us to: Second: Everything in government takes a whole lot longer than anyone expects. And the County Manager issue is a good example – we've been talking about this for at least ten years, and we may be on our way to a decision and detailed plan by the end of the year. But it has taken forever.

The reason is probably the combination of our reticence regarding long-term planning, and our actual system of governance. We've discussed the planning issue. Our system of governance really requires a thoughtful, complex path to completion, a path that takes time. There are a couple of reasons for this.

First, we have a number of layers of decision-making. On a Department level, decisions are made every day, but as plans, and the decisions needed to implement them, become more substantial and/or complex, they need to come to one or more Committees, and the Committees usually take a good deal of time to consider, come up with and deal with objections and alternatives, put it off for a while to think about it or to consult with others, etc. 

When this process is finally complete, and the Committee has agreed on an action, the action usually needs to come to the Administration Committee, which must approve spending, policy and plans that are above a certain level of cost, complexity, etc. Then, if and when the Admin Committee agrees (which, for bigger projects could also take many meetings, for the same reasons the Parent Committee took so long), the proposal needs to be drafted as a Board Resolution and voted on by the full Board. Since each of these entities (Parent Committee, Admin, Full Board) meet only once a month, even a relatively simple proposal could take months to work its way through.

There are pros and cons to taking a long time. We certainly give everyone a chance to weigh in, much time is spent in debate. But many things take too long. Again, we hope the insertion of a County Manager will help to speed this up without losing the thoughtful approach.

The second reason things take so long – and this is more opinion than system analysis – is that nobody likes change or spending a lot of money, and most of what we need to do requires both. It used to be that the Board included many members who were unwilling to spend any money at all, and spent a lot of time trying to slash the budget (not so much any more). So it's so much easier to kick the can down the road in the hopes that it will go away, and in many cases, this is what happened.

The Board needs to be wise stewards of the taxpayers' money, and we can never forget that. But stuff costs money. It's so often the case that expensive plans and proposals that are hotly debated will eventually save us money (Enterprise fleet management, preventive maintenance) or are just the right thing to do (M&C raises). You will get used to hearing the phrase “unfunded mandate,” which means that NYS has required Counties to do something expensive without providing any, or enough, funding to help pay for it. And so forth.

As we move forward, it is our hope that we can become an institution that plans well and pursues those plans in a timely manner.

Next - taxes!  Aren't you excited?

Life on the Board I - The Budget


First of all, thanks for running. Public service is difficult and largely thankless, but it is what America runs on. You continue an unbroken legacy that goes all the way back to the Founding Fathers, and before. Win or lose, you're willing to make a substantial contribution to your community – so thanks.

It's a good idea to start with the budget because this is the beginning of budget season. I wouldn't say that budget development consumes us, but it's never far from any conversation we have from now through December.

The first Budget Committee meeting was Monday morning, and we talked just in general terms about this challenges. The Budget Committee is the Administration Committee plus Andrew Marietta, but it's a public meeting and other Reps, and sometimes even candidates, attend pretty regularly. It's a really good place to get a long-term overview of County functioning. The next Budget Committee meeting is on Thursday, August 29 at 10:00 in the second floor committee room of the County Office Building.

The first thing that happens in the budget process is that the Treasurer “opens the budget tool.” The budget tool is software accessible by Department Heads, and is essentially the budget structure without any numbers in it. This has already happened; the budget tool is now “open,” and has been for a few weeks.

Ideally, Department Heads spend July filling in the budget tool. At the same time, they are presenting their budget for the next year to their parent committees. The Treasurer usually attends these Committee meetings to act as a resource. After whatever negotiation is necessary, the Department's final (up til that point) budget is entered into the budget tool.

Around the end of August, the budget tool is “closed,”, meaning that Department Heads cannot make any more changes. From then on, the Budget Committee meets pretty regularly and makes the changes necessary until, hopefully, around the middle of November, we have a balanced budget.

By the way - in many/most Counties, the Treasurer and the Budget Officer are two different people.  In Otsego County, the Treasurer is both.  If/when our County Manager comes on board, (s)he will almost certainly take on the role of Budget Officer. 

When the budget tool is closed, the Treasurer figures out the “gap” - the difference between revenue and expenses, given the budget lines as they stand at that time. The rest of the autumn is spent reducing that gap to zero. The Budget Committee can do it any way they want to, and often we call in Department Heads to talk about their requests, etc. The Treasurer is always there as a resource.

The budget gap is usually huge and scary – it has been as much as nine or ten million dollars – but there are always things to do – some hard, others easier – to bring it down to zero. By the way, our recent budgets have been around $110 million.

By state law, the Budget must be done by November 15. We usually have a public budget hearing at the Courthouse on the first Monday night of December, and no one ever comes. We can amend the budget by resolution until the budget is approved by the Board. We usually have a second full Board meeting in December, and that's when we approve the budget.

That's a quick overview of the way it works on paper. Watching the sausage being made in Budget Committee should add some important dimensions.

I'll be sending more summaries and overview of structure and function (and some opinions!) on an irregular basis.  Please let me know if there's anything you particularly want to know more about, and if/when you would like to meet to talk in more depth, etc.

(That last goes for you too, my hypothetical reader!)

Does This Thing Still Work?

Testing, testing...   one, two, one, two...

I'm back, for a short time.  I've been away for quite a while, almost entirely because I've had no evidence than anyone reads this blog.  For a while, it helped me organize my thoughts and keep track of the really wide variety of issues and directions that the Board is involved in.

But eventually, perhaps inevitably, I drifted away from preparing regular posts.  However, I'm currently involved in the process of supporting new candidates for Board seats - providing some background information and data, so they can discuss issues with constituents, and participate in debates, with more information at their command.

So I'm going to post my notes to the candidates here, for easier reference and, again, to organize and archive my thoughts on this interesting journey.

As you, my hypothetical reader, probably know, I will retire at the end of this term, December 31, 2019.  More on that, perhaps, later.  For now, I am looking forward to the energy, intelligence and commitment of those who will come after.

Thursday, January 25, 2018

Priorities for 2018

As promised, some discussion (a beginning, at least) of projects and directions that will be on the Board's agenda this year.

Certainly, the highest-profile issue on the agenda is the move toward professional management of County services. As I think I've noted before, Otsego County is the largest county in NY that does not have a County Manager or Executive (to be fair, Columbia County doesn't either, and it's almost exactly the same size). Over the years, more and more has been expected of counties by the state and federal bureaucracies, and nothing of note has been taken off of our plate. While it might have been possible for fourteen laymen to run Otsego County twenty years ago, it is less and less so as time goes on, and there is no evidence that this will change.

Professional management can take on any one of a number of formats. County Managers or Adminstrators are hired by the Board, usually for a specified term, and it is the Board that offers the opportunity for another term, or not. A County Executive is elected for a certain term in a county-wide election, and the voters determine whether another term is appropriate. Both forms of management have advocates in the County. I will dip into politics for just a moment to say that the leaders of the political party which represents the majority of voters supports, unsurprisingly, the County Executive model. I support the County Manager model, because I do want the Board to have clear oversight of the employee who will have day-to-day executive authority over all the workings of the County. And also because I am a member of the minority party.

Having a professional manager/executive/administrator at the top of the organizational chart will bring efficiency, an appropriate level of uniformity of function, and heightened transparency and communication to our very diverse set of functions and services. Simply said, it's crazy for a $110 million organization not to have a CEO.

Second on the list of 2018 goals, at least for me, will be a salary scale for Management and Confidential (M&C) employees, which pretty much means all non-union County employees. These are the department heads, and upper management and supervisors, for the most part, as well as a variety of professionals (Social Service attorneys, for instance). We finally got a raise for them in 2018 – the second in ten years – but it's for one year, and there is still no comprehensive, perpetual salary scale for determining reasonable increases for this important part of our County. We have serious problems with retention and promotion (promotion from a union position to an M&C position often does not include a meaningful wage hike) because of this.

I'll chair the committee (Performance Review and Goal Setting) that will address a salary study and scale, with the goal of having it in place by the time the 2019 budget is approved in December. This is an important goal for anyone who puts value on the quality of work done by County departments, rather than valuing the minimum output for the lowest cost.


Tuesday, January 16, 2018

2018

 Well, a lot has happened.

As you know, there is new leadership on the County Board for the first time in six years. Dave Bliss, from Middlefield, is now the Chair, and I am the Vice-Chair (which means only that I sit in the Chair when Dave can't be there).

If you're reading this blog, you probably know this, but humor me for a moment. In Europe (and probably in other places), countries often have many political parties on the nationial level – many more than the two which we have in the US - and so it is often the case that no political party wins a majority of the seats in the legislature. In this case, in order to govern (in other words, in order to pass legislation with a majority of votes), parties have to work together. Two or more parties end up coming to a set of agreements on policies and progress toward goals. This is known as a coalition government. Leadership in these countries has to focus on collaboration, compromise and diplomacy (which is necessary to keep the coalition together and functioning).

In most legislatures in America, there are two parties and one has the majority, and therefore governs. No compromise is necessary. But parties often have factions, which disagree about important issues, and therefore some initiatives need to be bipartisan. But for the most part, the majority rules.

This has been the case forever in Otsego County, until now. Republicans have maintained the majority on the County Board, for pretty much always. And that is true for 2018, as well – the Board is split 7-7, but the Republicans hold a slim weighted vote advantage.

However, the Board Republicans have split into two factions, for a number of reasons, and seem to be functioning as two different parties. After working closely with all the current Republicans for the last two years, it seemed that, from our standpoint, one faction was more progressive, and more aligned with our approach to County business, than the other. So the seven Democrats on the 2018 Board have allied with the faction headed by new Chair Dave Bliss, and have formed a coalition government.


As noted above, it will take compromise, collaboration and diplomacy to allow the coalition to work efficiently and maintain progress toward goals. So far, so good. Stay tuned. I'll talk more about specific projects and directions in future posts.

Saturday, December 30, 2017

Time

The Otsego County Board of Representatives Rules of Order (Rule #2) says that

Regular meetings of the Board shall be held at 10:00 a.m. on the first Wednesday of each month. All regular and special meetings of the Board shall be held at the Representatives' Chambers in the Village of Cooperstown, New York, except that upon approval of the affirmative weighted vote of at least three-fourths of the total membership of the Board, the time and meeting place of the Board may be changed...

So the time and day and place of the regular monthly meetings are baked into the Rules of Order, which are the Board's bylaws. And it takes three fourths of the board – three fourths! - to make a change.

Our monthly meetings are in the middle of the day, on a weekday (see below). The fact that it takes three fourths of the Board to change this – and nothing else we do is held to such a high standard – suggests something fishy, at least to me. When this rule was established, long ago, it was in someone's interest to make it very, very hard to change the meetings to the evenings, when many more of us can attend and participate. Having the meetings midday, midweek, means that it is much harder for nine-to-fivers to run and serve in the Board, and easier for small business owners, farmers and retired folks to run and serve. Guess which group the perpetual majority party is more likely to be made up of?

Time to move into the 21st century and embrace diversity and citizen participation. In the January meeting, Andrew Stammel will propose this change to the Rules of Order: that the time, day or place of the regular monthly Board meeting will be established by majority vote.

Majority vote is the way we make the vast majority of our decisions, profound or trivial. If the majority of the Board – this or any future Board – wants a change, they should be able to do it, and not be held hostage by the partisan machinations of long-forgotten members.   

Monday, December 11, 2017

Raises are Back!

Looking back over previous posts, I see we left the "raises for M&C employees" story in a perilous position.  Things are looking up.

I am on the Budget Committee this year, as well as Admin, and between the two, we managed to establish an M&C salary raise for 2018.  This was a very good budget year, compared with the last ten years or so, with a lot of financial issues falling the right way for us (including a robust sales tax report).  This led some other Board members to be a bit more accepting of the idea of giving our management their second raise in nine years.

Everyone (except elected officials) gets a raise; those who have been in their current positions longer get larger raises.  This coming year, the PRGS Committee will spend whatever amount of time it takes to develop a perpetual salary scale for M&C employees, so we won't have to do this again, and so our management staff get the raises they deserve on an onging basis.  We'll either find a consulting firm who can help us develop the scale, or develop it ourselves (the more likely, and less expensive, option), with the help of our outstanding Personnel Director, Penney Gentile.

Sunday, December 10, 2017

Time

Below is a list of current issues that the Otsego County Board of Representatives will be addressing, in the short or long term, in the new year. PLEASE let me know if you have any questions, concerns, ideas or suggestions regarding any of them. These are the things we'll be spending time and energy on, and we'd like to get them right.

One issue that may come as a surprise is the time of day that the Board meeting is held. In Otsego County, the Board meets as a whole on the first Wednesday of each month, at 10:00 in the morning. This means that, in general, people who have regular nine-to-five or other types of weekday jobs probably can't attend our meetings, either to speak their minds, as they have a right to do, or just to watch, observe, listen and learn.

In addition, of course, this restriction applies to anyone thinking of running for the Board, as well. With daytime meetings, you'd really have to own your own business (including a farm), be retired, or have a job with very flexible hours. Not surprisingly, those are the kinds of folks the Board is populated with. Nothing wrong with that, except that the daytime meeting time is keeping a lot of people with other kinds of jobs from running. I was actually looking into running in 2005, before I retired, and my boss – OCSD Superintendent Mike Shea, a great lover of history and government – had to ask me not to, as he felt the daytime meetings would have too great an impact on my work.


About half of all upstate rural NY Counties have their full Board meetings in late afternoon or the evening, so it can be done. It's time we opened the democratic process in Otsego County to everyone.

County Issues as of Now

CURRENT ISSUES – Late 2017

To be addressed before Jan 2018 Board meeting:
  • Leadership – determining how everyone in the coaliton communicates and collaborates to develop an agenda and process for going forward.
  • Committees – Assignment of committee chairs; assignment of Board members to committees. Committee structure – Maintain current committees as is, or make changes? Ag Committee, or centralize Ag work in one committee – SWEC?
  • Meeting times – Daytime meetings close many people out of participation, either from attending meetings or running for Board seats. Change Board meetings to 6PM? How about Committee meetings?
Issues requiring longer-term planning, starting soon:
  • County Manager – how to begin talking/acting on this? Task Force? Assign to Committee? Lots of data has already been gathered.
  • Salary Study – Either contract with a consultant to create a perpetual salary scale, or make one up ourselves. PRGS Committee?
  • Strategic Plan – How to go forward with this. Continue with current process (separate Committee)? How to establish clear guidelines for implementation?
  • Communication with Department Heads – How to encourage regular, significant communication, empowering them and using their expertise to address current issues and to see what's coming and how to plan for it. Planning in general – How can we elicit and organize large amounts of information to facilitate medium and long-term planning in all areas of County function? How can we enroll Dept Heads and management staff in this process?
  • Jail: Upgrade, expand, replace?

New systems to routinely monitor and assess, and report regularly to full Board
  • Onondaga County – Otsego Co. Purchasing Dept. - Need a Rep, or a staff person, or a Committee to be dedicated liaison
  • Enterprise Fleet Management – Public Works? Need to support a seamless transition and keep our eye on costs.
  • Towers – Finish the job, sell the Rose Hill land. Assurance that both the function of the towers and their maintenance are working as planned. How can we monetize the towers?
  • Economic development – Obviously, a big issue and a lot of work. Otsego Now must be reformed and empowered. Existing jobs that are not being taken by local people: Springbrook/ARCOtsego; agriculture; hospitality.
  • Budget – Planning for 2019 – new Treasurer, new process? Does it make sense to find ways to keep track of the budget process all year long? Do we need a Finance Committee that also does the Budget?
  • County Forester (Soil & Water) – SWEC tracks progress toward explicit goals
  • Ethics Board
  • Various litigation issues

Going Forward

It's been a long time, again, and a lot has been done.

Since August, I have been working with the Democratic candidates for County Rep; other than Andrew Marietta and Andrew Stammel, they were all new to the work of the County Representative. I provided a lot of background regarding Board structure and function, as well as very extensive communications and conversations about particular issues that the Board has been working on. This work intensified during the run-up to the debates, which were held in a variety of places throughout the County.

Four of the new candidates, as well as Andrew and Andrew and I, were elected, and we had what turned out to be a pretty joyful election night celebration. As of January 1 there will be seven Democrats on the Board, although the Republicans represent a slight majority in weighted votes. But the Republicans may not be unified regarding Board leadership as we go forward, and there is a distinct possibility that we Democrats will be participating in what can only be called a coalition government when the gavel comes down on January 3.

I try to avoid partisan politics in these messages, but at this point I think it's important to lay out how things stand. There are some Republicans who have expressed dissatisfaction with current leadership. However, they cannot prevail without Democratic votes. So we will all be talking about how we can go forward, supporting each others' vision for the County and the major issues we are facing.


I think we will be able to work out a plan which will satisfy everyone. There's a lot of work to do, and I think that with a commitment to transparency, communication and bipartisan cooperation, we'll get that work done. Stay tuned.