Remember - blog posts migrate downward, so the most recent post is at the top; the oldest at the bottom.

Friday, April 13, 2012

I asked the folks at the County Planning Department (Karen Sullivan and Psalm Wyckoff) about the parking lot today, and they were generous with their time and very helpful. Karen made some calls later on and filled in some blanks. It seems it's a three-part story.

(People who work with planning, zoning and code enforcement speak their own language, fluently and swiftly, and it's a language that I don't speak, yet, so some of the vocabulary may be misplaced or inaccurate.)

The land being developed for the parking lot straddles the town-city line, so the code inspectors and Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) in both municipalities are involved. In both the town and the city, the original application for permits was denied, but the ZBA in the City approved a use variance. The Town ZBA has deemed the application incomplete, so no decision has been made there. So at this point, the project is not approved. It's not clear whether the project can go ahead in the city section without the whole thing being approved by both municipalities.

The County gets involved if a project is within 500' of a municipal boundary, and this one fits because it's right on a municipal boundary. However, this is where it gets interesting: the project began, apparently, as a collection of townhouses, and it was sent to the County at that point, about two years ago. Now that the plans have changed, it's not clear whether the City or the town will request that the County look at the project and then make recommendations.  The County's rulings in these cases are usually focused on whether the project in one municipality will cause an undue burden on the neighboring municipality, and these rulings are only recommendations; they have no authority over the municipality's final decision.  When the County is asked to get involved (and it only gets involved when a municipality requests it), it can do one of four things: approve, disapprove, approve with modifications, or decline to rule because no significant impact has been found.

And finally, the City Code Enforcement office is asking DEC to become involved with the project; more on this as time goes on.

Overall, this project is raising a lot of questions. Apparently, the plan is to market the parking spaces to freshmen for long-term parking, although whether there is a sufficient market to make the project pay is one of those questions. The owner is hoping to get OPT to stop there – but where? It's a busy, residential corner, and for most of the project's length, East Street has a 45 mph speed limit. Not a great place for buses to stop every fifteen minutes.

Anyway, more to come. At least we can be assured that there are people in the middle of this who are asking the right questions. If you want to take more action, contact:

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

The Parking Lot

I've gotten a number of calls and e-mails regarding the planned parking lot at the top of East St., where Bugbee Rd. and Meadowbrook Lane intersect it. The vacant lots on that corner, on either side of Meadowbrook Lane, have been bulldozed and graded recently, in preparation for what the owner hopes will be a lot for long-term parking for 300+ student cars.

Everyone who contacted me had concerns about the project, concerns that I share. Many questions are unanswered: questions about foot traffic crossing East St. and traveling through neighborhoods, security, lighting, runoff (and many other environmental concerns), increased traffic, and others.

I went to City Hall to talk with Robert Chiappisi, city Code Enforcement Officer, last week. Many factors make this a complex issue. The land is part in the City, and part in the Town, which (usually but not always) means that the County gets involved. The project has been given a preliminary variance, but each step requires approval, and Mr. Chiappisi, who will be making the decisions about those approvals, has grave concerns about the project as well.

I'll be at the Meadows for a committee meeting on Friday, and I'll stop in at the County Planning Department office and see if I can learn anything more about how this all works, and what's in store for that neighborhood. I'll let you know what I learn, here at the weblog. Stay tuned.

Friday, April 6, 2012

MOSA Letter

If you were down to the Oneonta MOSA transfer station in March, you might have been handed a letter from the Executive Director of MOSA, Dennis Heaton, listing reasons why he thought Otsego County's plan to depart from MOSA was a bad idea – specifically, because it will cost Otsego County citizens a lot more to dispose of their trash: “In summary, Otsego County citizens will pay substantially more if Otsego departs MOSA.”

I don't know about you, but I don't think this was a good idea – especially since Mr. Heaton didn't inform the MOSA Board that he was going to distribute a one-sided argument on an important and complex topic to whoever showed up at the transfer station. There are better ways to get your point across, in our media-rich world. Worse, it turns out that his facts were cherry-picked and incomplete; he did not mention, in many instances, many of the MOSA expenditures which would occur even if Otsego County remained with the Authority.

Cathy Clark, the Otsego County Board Chair, wrote to Mr. Heaton, outlining the errors in his presentation, and calling his attempt to 'impugn' and 'undermine' a member county of the Authority 'regrettable.' I'd be glad to send you a copy of it if you'd like to read it, especially if you've seen Mr. Heaton's letter.

The truth is, we don't know the details of how everything is going to work out. The County Board decided to leave MOSA well before I arrived, and everything I've heard convinces me that it was a good decision. It's a decision we're going to stick with, and I think it's going to turn out well for the citizens of Otsego County.

Friday, February 17, 2012

Child Safety Zone law

I have to agree with the majority on the Public Safety Committee (a standing Committee of the County Board), who this week voted to recommend that Otsego County's Child Safety Zone law be rescinded. It seems that the law – which forbids registered sex offenders from living within 1,000 feet of any school, school bus stop, day care center, youth center, swimming pool, or any “public or commercial recreational facility clearly designed to attract children” - is probably unconstitutional. In fact, a number of other similar laws, passed in other NY counties, have been challenged in court; the county lost every time, and no county has appealed, suggesting that their claim to constitutionality was not strong.

Regardless of whether it it's constitutional or not, it doesn't make a lot of sense, except on an emotional level. There's no research anywhere suggesting that this kind of law has any effect on recidivism; we can't prove that it keeps any children safe. Anyone can travel a thousand feet – or, for that matter, ten miles – from where they live to where children congregate.

What they can't do, given the law as it now stands, is live in most Otsego County housing. A thousand feet is nearly a quarter mile, and if you draw a circle around every school, park, daycare and (especially) school bus stop, there's not much left. Especially in small towns where housing clusters around the school. And in a rural county, where school buses stop at nearly every house, even options outside of town are limited. Just think about the geography of District 11, here in the First and Second Wards: try and picture the map, and find a house or apartment more than 1,000 feet from a park or a school, or Bugbee, or the SUCO playing fields.

Given the nature of the offense, it is appropriate for some sex offenders to incur further restrictions on their liberty after their prison sentence is over; our public safety officials assure us that this is done with energy and effectiveness. But to make it almost impossible for any of them to find adequate, stable housing seems to assume that none of them will become productive, contributing citizens, and thus can be marginalized and dismissed.

This debate brings to mind the capital punishment issue: in both cases, a draconian punishment is applied not because it will change behavior or promote anyone's safety, but because it will be emotionally satisfying to a large portions of the citizenry This aspect has its value – but it also has its consequences.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

E-911 Addresses

Some folks on Forest Ave. have contacted me about letters they received from the E-911 system, informing them that they had to change their house numbers. I spoke with the Sheriff a couple of weeks ago, and he assured me that these changes have been put on indefinite hold.

As you may know, the E-911 system was moved to the Sheriff's office in November, and they are still adjusting to some of the changes that were taking place as the transition occurred. As of now, however, it's important that numbers don't change on houses, stationery, bills, databases, etc.

The Daily Star goes into this in a little more detail here.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Mandates and their Relief

My wife and I own some land in Lewis County, NY, and when we got the tax bill this year, attached to it was a one-page “Truth in Taxation Report.” Sent out in accordance with new County legislation, the report is, it says, “...designed to provide a legal mechanism to ensure that citizens receive accurate tax bill information on State Mandated Programs and the effects on County Budget. State Mandates are established by the State, with no County input, and are paid for through the property tax.”

There follows a list of eight major Lewis County programs required by NY State law, and the cost of each. The total (over 11 million dollars for a county more rural than Otsego) is provided, and then the kicker: this total accounts for 90% of the entire tax levy.

Enthusiastic capitalization notwithstanding, this is an intriguing report, and the clarity of its presentation makes a clear and cogent point. I attended an all-day workshop for new County legislators a couple of weeks ago (presented expertly by the NY State Association of Counties (NYSAC)), and heard a lot about state mandates; 90% seems pretty typical, but one of the suburban counties south of us (Rockland, I think) was up to 120%. 
 
Many programs and processes required of counties in NY are reimbursed by the state, but many are not; it's not clear whether Lewis County's 90% was made up entirely of the latter, but either way, this is an important point. In most counties, Medicaid comprises the largest of these items (by far), and the county taxpayer would be justified in scratching his/her head and asking, “But I though Medicaid was a Federal program?”

It is, but states pay up to half the bill, for reasons I don't have room to go into here. And for other reasons, even more obscure and complex, only about half of the states require Counties to pitch in. According to a National Association of Counties 2010 report, New York counties pay many times more (a total of over $6 billion) than the counties of any other state – including California, whose overall Medicaid bill is half as much again as New York's.

The Governor's budget, being negotiated right now, includes what has been touted as 'mandate relief,' but, in these tough times, the dollar amounts are relatively small. Counties won't be paying less for anything, as it stands now; however, increases in the various bills will be capped (and, in the case of Medicaid, eliminated), eventually.

All this has an impact on Otsego County's budgeting process, and eventually on the tax bill we all pay. We can't cut mandated services, whatever we think of them, and so we need to look elsewhere. “Elsewhere” is getting smaller and smaller. Saying that 90% of the tax levy is mandated services is fudging the whole truth a little bit, but overall, the impact is substantial and is a major issue for us to address in the coming years.

By the way, if you want to let your NY State legislators know how you feel about this, here's where to do it:

Governor Andrew Cuomo's website
NY State Senator Jim Seward's website
NY Assemblyman Jim Magee's website 
and/or use NYSAC's simple form letter 

Month and a Half In

It's been a fascinating time, this last month and a half. Starting with the (for me, at least) moving and exciting swearing-in (actually, I was sworn in three times; long story), our first Pledge of Allegiance (“...and liberty and justice for all!”), and the seven-ballot Chair voting (which, I think, has turned out extremely well), a lot of the work has turned out to be routine. With the exception of those Chair ballots, and the resolution supporting home rule for gas drilling regulation, the vast majority of the resolutions that have come before the Board have been passed unanimously.

Committee meetings, so far, have been routine, as well; I'm on the Human Services and Health & Education Committees, both of which I requested (thanks, Cathy!). I must compliment every Department director and commissioner for their graceful willingness to outline, for us newbies, the scope and function of their Department's work. I also had the opportunity to attend six hours of workshops designed to orient new employees (and new Board members) to the Department of Social Services. I've had a number of contacts from other Department heads, offering to do the same. Everyone's been friendly and eager to help, which I appreciate immensely.

There are some important issues that will challenge us this year: the post-MOSA world; hydrofracking home rule (however it comes out on the State level); the sex-offender housing law; next year's budget, and whatever surprises await us. I'll do my best to report on these and other county issues as they occur.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

The Housing Summit

It's been a while since I last posted – there's a lot happening, and I've been out of town a lot. I'll be updating a few times in the next few days.

Yesterday morning I walked down to Center Street Elementary to take part in the Mayor's Housing Summit. The gymnasium was packed; they had to to bring out a lot more chairs. Great coffee and donuts from Foti's. We were homeowners, landlords, tenants, government officials, realtors, and everyone had a lot to say.

We addressed a handful of questions ranging from fully using the upper floors of downtown buildings to improving the living conditions of seniors. Plans were made for subgroups to go deeper into each challenging area. More to come on this.

To my ears, there was a subtext that was a little disturbing. A lot of conversation revolved around student housing and (less explicitly) low-income neighborhoods. There seemed to be an assumption that living near either group was undesirable, and that high concentrations of either group made development of owner-occupied homes more difficult. Statistics regarding property values may bear this out, and there seemed to be general agreement that they diminish the quality of life in the vicinity. Owner-occupied housing, it appeared, located a discreet distance from student and low-income housing, was the gold standard.

Not that anyone came right out and said this. So – I could be wrong. Explicit or not, this is undoubtedly a widely held approach to the housing questions in any city.

Most of you know where I live – on Center St., next to the creek. We have student houses on two sides, and one of those houses rents to baseball campers in the summer. A lot of folks in difficult circumstances live within a block or two. We're happy to have all of them as neighbors. The only noise problem we've ever had here was when the City put that pump in the creek.

We're all going to be living here in Oneonta for a long time, and it's really too small a town for robust homogenous neighborhoods. For us, that's a good thing. We like the diversity all around us. At the Summit, I talked some with a landlord who owns a lot of student housing, and he was very clear about the standard of behavior he imposes on any renter who wants to stay. It works. Most students are good neighbors, and there are ways to assure that they all are. Poor folks want to live in nice places, in good neighborhoods, just as much as everyone else; sometimes, they just need a little help – or opportunity.

So I'd like to see the work started yesterday to move toward ways of coming together and living cooperatively in the City, and not toward ways of distancing ourselves from each other. I've got some ideas along those lines, so – more to come!

Thursday, January 5, 2012

The First Meeting

I'm not sure I'll be posting about each meeting; I'd rather talk about issues and planning. But this was the first meeting for me, and therefore, significant.

The meeting began with calling the roll. After the Pledge, we were all sworn in by Judge Brian Burns. He began by telling us that he had run across a copy of Board minutes from 1804, and was struck by the similarities he found between that meeting and this. In 1804, it was very probable that the founder of Cooperstown and the driving force behind the creation of Otsego County, Judge William Cooper, was in the room, or nearby, ready to provide his wisdom, influence or experience to the legislators.

As we were sworn in, we faced the folks who had come to speak, and to listen, and I saw the importance of this moment reflected in some of the faces: lighter, vibrant, luminous. This was a moving and significant moment for me – and, I'm sure, for my colleagues – and it seemed that the folks in the back of the room understood that – which made it all the more special.

On to business. After a protracted nomination process and debate, we elected the first female Chair of the Otsego County Board in history. More details in the Daily Star article. Kathy Clark will be a fine Chair; she got a good start on Wednesday.

After dozens of routine approvals, we got to the Home Rule resolution, which is what most of the folks in the back of the room had come for. Earlier in the meeting, there had been a very long public comment period; speakers from both sides of the fracking issues made their cases, without exception, passionately and articulately. Our debate focused more tightly on the details of the resolution before us: it was simply a resolution of support for Senator Seward's legislation empowering each local municipality to determine whether or not to allow hydrofracking within its borders. I voted for the resolution (more detail here), as did all Board members who had run on an anti-fracking platform, and it passed. I still don't quite understand why we should oppose letting our Town Boards make decisions about something this significant.

Next meeting is next week (Wednesday, January 11 at 6:00 PM), when committee assignments are made. This is an important process, and one that highlights the power of the Chair. Here's hoping the assignments are made in a truly bipartisan manner, allowing all Board members to make a difference.

Friday, December 30, 2011

Senator Seward's Survey

I assume that you all got the same survey in the mail that I did, from NY State Senator Seward's office. He asks a few simple questions about some important topics, and leaves room for comment.

One of the questions involves the home rule issue for gas drilling. Sen. Seward has proposed legislation allowing local municipalities (county, town, city) to restrict, regulate or ban the kind of heavy industry that hydrofracking represents. This is a very difficult and controversial topic – giving us local folks the ability to say “no” to some of the largest corporations in the world.

If you agree that this is an important issue for us here in Otsego County, I would urge you to complete the survey and send it in. Make your opinion known. We are at a point in time where we are able to have an impact at the point of action. Let's not miss it.

If you didn't get a survey, or don't have it any more, you can complete it at Sen. Seward's website. I looked there and didn't find it, so I've contacted Sen. Seward's office and I will update here as soon as I get a reply.

UPDATE:  1-10-12:  The survey is now up on the site, available from the home page - just click on "Share Your Ideas for a Stronger New York."